The argumentation over whether to expose a real or an unreal Christmas tree diagram dates back to the 1930s . That was when a lavatory brush manufacturer - Addis Brush society - discover it could make an hokey Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree using the same bristles it used in its brush . ( Before that , many artificial trees were made of feathers dye greenish . ) At the time , it provided folks across the country a answer to a job they did n’t even experience they had : the likely mess that comes with a natural tree .

There are sure as shooting some benefits to go artificial . It save money over time , and may be the only option for renters . But , for me , real is the way to go . Perhaps it is my roots as a Yankee who spent timber metre with my dad detect that perfect Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree at gelded - your - own tree farms . Or , perhaps it ’s because I married a tree farmer who share my love for seeing just how big a tree diagram we can tweet through our patio doors and then put up underneath our 19 - foot overleap ceiling .

Our first choice run to be a balsam true fir . This is partly due to its availability in the county forest we subsist in , but its sturdy branch lend themselves well to hanging innumerous ornament showcasing our vacations , milestones and tiddler ’s creations . And then there is , of trend , the smell . It is distinct . You either have intercourse it or hate it . For our family , it is synonymous with the vacation time of year .

Norway pine in the wild – istockphoto image

Norway pine in the wild — istockphoto image

A close runner - up that is perhaps more appropriate for this column is the Norway true pine . AsMinnesota ’s prescribed land tree , the imperial Norway pine is a favorite of Minnesotans seeking that perfect tree . Norway pine tree , often called red pine , became the official province tree in 1953 . The Minnesota Legislature denominate the Norway pine as the province tree because of “ the sturdiness and loftiness of the tree , and how it helped lay the instauration for the wealth of Minnesota . ” This workhorse , while not as fragrant as some choice , is known for its needle retentivity . The needles , which are 3 to 5 inches in length , give it a distinct look compared to some of the other tree favorites . likewise to the balsam , it hold up a lot of ornamentation that are n’t extraordinarily heavy .

As a landscape tree , Norway pine tree should only be grown in full sun and wide - open areas . It matures to 50 to 75 feet tall with a spread of 40 feet . The tree is useful in windbreak , especially in field with sandy soils .

According to theMinnesota Christmas Tree Association , a few other tree diagram favourite in Minnesota include the Canaan and Frasier true fir ; Scotch and white pines ; and Colorado , Norway and blue spruce trees . Each one comes with a distinct look , fragrance and metier , providing myriad options for those who want to stick with real trees .

Tree BASIC

Despite my dearest of a substantial tree , there are a few lessons I ’ve acquire the hard way that challenged this beloved . First , never underestimate the power and importance of a sturdy Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree point of view . secondly , meditate the possible action of reinforcing your tree to a wall ( or three in our type ) . This becomes particularly true when you have a toddler or combat-ready pet . Third , if you’re able to , keep your tree away from main warmth sources . Fourth , when you bring your tree plate , do n’t forget to trim the bottom inch of the Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree to reopen the tree stanch so it can absorb water . in the end , water is your good friend . I often block that an average - sized tree can drink up to 2 gallons of piss in the first daytime alone ! As for what type of water to use , inquiry shows that you’re able to steer clear of additives and utilise just good one-time tap pee .

Finding a natural tree in Minnesota is easy . There are more than 40cut - your - own Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree farmsin the area , not to mention countless corner tree stands . Those more adventuresome will desire to mark with county , state or federal forests on the permitting process for scouting out their own tree . Just be sure to stay off of private land .

While the argumentation over existent versus artificial may never stop , the most important matter to recall is that it is n’t so much the tree diagram you choose , but rather the custom and memory that take place around it .

This chromatography column byBeth Probstwas in the beginning print in the November / December 2016 issue ofNorthern Gardeneras part of a series on inheritance plants . Beth is a freelance writer based in Iron River , Wis.